With each annual release of MLB The Show, players eagerly anticipate the announcement of new legends joining the game’s iconic Diamond Dynasty mode. These additions not only celebrate the history of baseball but also provide fresh gameplay experiences, allowing fans to build dream teams across generations. As MLB The Show 25 continues to MLB The Show 25 Stubs refine its gameplay, graphics, and player content, fans have flooded forums and social media with their ideal legends wishlist—iconic players who have yet to grace the virtual field.
Here’s a deep dive into the top most requested legends for MLB The Show 25, complete with why they deserve a place in the game, their potential ratings, and what they’d bring to the Diamond Dynasty ecosystem.
1. Barry Bonds – The Home Run King
Why He’s Wanted:
Arguably the most controversial and celebrated player in MLB history, Barry Bonds holds the all-time home run record with 762 bombs and a career OPS of 1.051. Despite his complicated legacy due to steroid allegations, Bonds’ absence in The Show has left a gaping hole for over a decade. His unique blend of power, patience, and speed would make him one of the most valuable cards in Diamond Dynasty.
Potential Card Attributes:
125 Power vs. RHP / LHP
110+ Vision and Discipline
85+ Speed
Diamond-tier Fielding in LF with a Cannon Arm
Dream Card: 2001 MVP Barry Bonds – 73 HR season, with maxed out offensive stats.
2. Ichiro Suzuki – The Hit Machine
Why He’s Wanted:
Ichiro is the perfect representation of a contact-focused legend with elite defense and base-running skills. With over 3,000 MLB hits and 10 consecutive Gold Gloves in right field, Ichiro’s card would shake up the meta by rewarding players who rely on speed and contact hitting.
Potential Card Attributes:
125 Contact vs. RHP / LHP
99 Speed and Stealing
95+ Fielding with 99 Arm Accuracy
High Clutch and Durability
Dream Card: 2004 Ichiro – the year he broke the single-season hits record (262).
3. Roger Clemens – The Rocket Returns
Why He’s Wanted:
Like Bonds, Roger Clemens has been left out of The Show due to licensing issues and steroid-era stigma. But there’s no denying his dominance across multiple decades, with seven Cy Young Awards and over 4,600 strikeouts. Adding Clemens would bring a high-Velocity, high-Control ace to the rotation pool.
Potential Card Attributes:
99 Stamina
99 H/9 and K/9
Signature Fastball, Splitter, Slider, and Curveball
80+ Control and Break on all pitches
Dream Card: 1997 Blue Jays Clemens – 21-7 record, 2.05 ERA, 292 K.
4. Josh Gibson – The Negro League Legend
Why He’s Wanted:
With MLB The Show 23’s addition of Negro League players, the community has been hoping for Josh Gibson’s arrival ever since. Known as the "Black Babe Ruth," Gibson reportedly hit over 800 home runs and was a force at the plate.
Potential Card Attributes:
125 Power vs. RHP / LHP
100+ Contact
Catcher position flexibility with decent defensive skills
High Clutch and Durability
Dream Card: Legends Showcase Josh Gibson – high offense catcher to challenge Mike Piazza and Joe Mauer in endgame lineups.
5. Pedro Martinez – The Power Pitching Magician
Why He’s Wanted:
Though Pedro Martinez was previously in The Show, he’s been missing in recent versions. Fans are clamoring for his return with a juiced Signature Series card that captures his Cy Young years with the Red Sox.
Potential Card Attributes:
High 90s Fastball, devastating Changeup and Slider
110+ K/9
Deceptive delivery animations and pinpoint control
Endgame caliber SP for ranked play
Dream Card: 1999 Pedro – 23-4, 2.07 ERA, 313 K.
6. Bo Jackson – The Two-Sport Marvel
Why He’s Wanted:
Bo Jackson has long been the stuff of video game legend thanks to Tecmo Bowl, but in baseball, he was equally electrifying. His rocket arm, home run power, and breakneck speed make him a perfect fan-favorite for Diamond Dynasty.
Potential Card Attributes:
100+ Power
95+ Speed
99 Arm Strength
Dual position eligibility (CF, RF, LF)
Dream Card: All-Star Bo Jackson – the perfect combination of raw tools and athletic dominance.
7. Joe DiMaggio – The Yankee Clipper
Why He’s Wanted:
Despite the popularity of Babe Ruth, Lou Gehrig, and Mickey Mantle in The Show, Joe DiMaggio has been notably absent. DiMaggio’s 56-game hitting streak, elite center field defense, and prestige as a Yankee legend would easily land him as a top-tier card.
Potential Card Attributes:
110+ Contact
85+ Power
90+ Fielding and Reaction
Balanced offensive threat with historical flair
Dream Card: 1941 DiMaggio – during his famous hit streak.
8. Fernando Valenzuela – The Fernandomania Phenomenon
Why He’s Wanted:
Valenzuela’s screwball and unorthodox delivery made him a sensation in the '80s. While previously featured in past versions of The Show, a high-tier Signature Valenzuela is still absent in MLB The Show 25.
Potential Card Attributes:
Unique Screwball and Curveball with elite break
High Stamina
Strong against contact-focused lineups
Signature quirks and flair
Dream Card: 1981 Rookie of the Year and Cy Young Valenzuela – 180 K in 192 IP.
Conclusion: Legends Bring Nostalgia and Strategy
As MLB The Show 25 looks to expand its roster of historical greats, the demand for these legends is louder than ever. Players like Barry Bonds, Ichiro, and Pedro Martinez don’t just bring numbers—they bring emotion, history, and fandom to the MLB The Show 25 Stubs for sale game. The integration of these legends would also introduce new team-building strategies, shifting the meta in Ranked Seasons, Battle Royale, and Events.
San Diego Studio has already shown commitment to historical excellence by including Negro League content and showcasing forgotten legends. If even a handful of these wishlist legends make their debut in MLB The Show 25, it could be the most complete and nostalgic entry in the franchise yet.
Whether you're building an all-time Yankees squad, a power-only dream team, or a roster full of speed demons, these legends would inject new life into Diamond Dynasty and ensure that every game you play is a journey through baseball history.
